Best Comedy - Community
Most Underrated Show - House of Lies
Most Overrated Show - NCIS
Best Reality Show Host or Judge - Cat Deeley, So You Think You Can Dance. No question about that one.
Worst Reality Show Host or Judge - Christina Milian, The Voice. Maybe not the "worst", just the most useless.
Most Painful Series Cancellation - The Secret Circle. Honestly, I'm still crying about The Chicago Code being unjustly cancelled last year, so it's hard to pick this time around.
Best Season Finale - Castle. I was going to pick TVD, but since Ern already did, I decided to show Castle some love.
Worst Season Finale - How I Met Your Mother
Most Anticipated New Show of the 2012-2013 Season - The Mob Doctor
Worst New Show - Betty White's Off Their Rockers
Worst Returning Show - NCIS
Best Badass - Arya Stark, Game of Thrones
Best Performance by an Inanimate Object - The Jenna List, Awkward.
New Series with the Most Wasted Potential - Terra Nova (though we both agree that Awake should be on that list)
Most Improved Show - 30 Rock
Most Disappointing Season of a Previously Awesome Show - Bones
Favorite Character - Hanna, Pretty Little Liars
Least Favorite Character - Byron, Pretty Little Liars
Best Scene-stealing Supporting Character - Shoshanna, Girls
Best Cancelled 2011-2012 Show - Prime Suspect
Best Late Night Talk Show - The Late Late Show with Craig Ferguson
Favorite Animated Show - Phineas & Ferb
Best Competitive Reality Show - So You Think You Can Dance (though every year, I agonize over whether to pick SYTYCD or Big Brother)
Best Candid Reality Show - Storage Wars
Worst Candid Reality Show - H8R
Most Annoying Teenage Character - Charlotte, Revenge